Word leaks fast in local TV. Especially when a familiar anchor waves goodbye — or three do, one after another. If you scroll West Michigan Reddit or peek at your favorite news Facebook group, you’ve probably spotted whispers: “Is there a mass exodus?” “What is happening at Fox 17?”
It sounds dramatic. But does it hold up? Let’s hit pause, shake out the rumors, and see what the data (and actual exit statements) tell us.
Recent High-Profile Departures: Who Went Where and Why?
Let’s start with the basics. Four big on-air names left Fox 17 News in the past year. That’s enough to get viewers speculating — and competitors eyeing résumés. Let’s break down the who, the when, and, crucially, the why.
Andrea Shaner: Veteran Executive Producer Trades Newsroom for New Hemisphere
Eighteen years at one local station is a lifetime in TV years — and that’s what executive producer Andrea Shaner banked before packing up. Her reason? Hardly mysterious. Shaner’s husband landed an opportunity in Australia, and she did what most would do: she prioritized family, crossed a hemisphere, and wrote a farewell any HR director wishes they could bottle.
No coded language. No parting shots. Just, “It’s been a wild ride, see you on the next continent.” Per Shaner’s own social media and coverage, it’s about family relocation, not anything brewing behind the Fox 17 curtain.
Tessa DiTirro: Back to Cleveland (and Family Brunches)
Next up: Tessa DiTirro, the station’s 5 a.m. face for morning viewers. In 2023, DiTirro left after several years on air, trading early alarms for a morning anchor role at Fox 8 in Cleveland. Again, the headlines write themselves: returning home, closer to family, and — bonus — joining a sister station.
DiTirro didn’t air dirty laundry. She didn’t hint at lost faith in management. She wanted to live and work in the city where she has roots and weekend brunch with her parents. In broadcast TV, this is par for the course (even if it stings for West Michigan viewers who liked her Monday energy).
Candace Monacelli: Seven Years, Many Forecasts, Zero Drama
Meteorologist Candace Monacelli signed off in July 2024 after seven years at Fox 17. But if you’re hunting for a scandal, keep scrolling. Monacelli’s public messages — and friends’ social posts — focused on the “incredible ride,” her professional growth, and what’s next.
She didn’t cite any conflict, bad weather (so to speak), or friction with the team. Her exit notes were all about gratitude, challenges overcome, and optimism for the future.
Deanna Falzone: Departure with Dignity (and Some Mystery)
Last one on the list: Deanna Falzone, another familiar face. Falzone announced her farewell via broadcast and social — but with much less detail than the others. She thanked colleagues, talked family time, and kept it tactful, not dramatic.
Was it about internal friction? If so, there’s no hint in public statements. Sometimes people crave privacy — especially in an industry that lives for public storytelling.
Why Are These People Really Leaving? Let’s Zoom Out
Now let’s get practical. Across these departures, three reasons pop up: family relocation, personal growth, and career opportunities elsewhere.
That’s not a Fox 17 problem. That’s broadcast news in 2024.
If you know anyone who works in local media, you’ll hear the same themes, station to station. The life cycle of a news anchor or producer? Move to a new market, polish your on-camera (and “on-Zoom”) game, get closer to family, or leap into a bigger role. Often the first two, sometimes all three.
The trade-off: TV news is built on individuals, but the industry asks them to be mobile. It’s whiplash for loyal viewers, but not for anyone working behind the scenes.
Take Andrea Shaner’s leap to Australia — about as clear a family move as you’ll find. Or Tessa DiTirro’s return to Cleveland — it doesn’t get more “personal reasons” than rejoining your home city. Neither points to drama at the station.
Bottom line: these exits fit classic industry patterns.
Sounds Like a Mass Exodus? Not So Fast
Now for the fun part: internet speculation. If you only heard about these changes through the grapevine, you’d think the newsroom was emptying out faster than most people’s inboxes on a Friday.
But if you read the actual statements? It’s barely a ripple — not a crisis.
Here are the facts:
- There are four high-profile departures in about 12 months.
- All public messages focus on family, new jobs, or future plans.
- Zero mention of toxic workplaces, management shakeups, or contract spats.
Sure, four exits in a year draws attention. But cycle through the staff rosters at any TV station in the country: this is normal. Broadcast is a small pond — and a restless one.
Every year, hundreds of local anchors, meteorologists, and producers move towns, swap roles, or try a new industry. Stations usually air a highlight reel, send out a press release, and bring in new faces. All while regulars reload the rumor mill. The churn is the system.
The real trick? Spotting the difference between typical turnover and “uh-oh, something broke” — and here, there’s no sign of the latter.
What Actually Drives Turnover in Local TV News?
Let’s break it down, business-style.
Industry churn: TV news is already at 25-30% annual turnover, per the RTDNA/Newhouse Survey. Local anchors often last 2-5 years; producers last even less.
Pay and relocation: Job offers in bigger (or more familiar) markets mean higher pay and family proximity. It’s the classic “move up or move home” story.
Quality of life: If you want steady hours or weekends off, local news isn’t winning votes. The rise in remote options post-2020 has pulled some broadcasters elsewhere.
So, is Fox 17’s turnover above market rate? Not with this sample size — and, crucially, not given the reasons cited.
Let’s Cut Through the Rumor Machine: No Red Flags Found
Sometimes staff exit for all the wrong reasons: newsroom shakeups, new bosses, sudden pay cuts, even scandals. When this happens, you see very different clues — think anonymous leaks, abrupt anchor swaps, “we wish them well” statements laced with shade.
So far, Fox 17’s batch of farewells has none of that. If you scroll through their coverage, these are classic, even upbeat, industry transitions.
The gossip is inevitable — social media fuels speculation, and everyone loves a “what’s really happening?” headline. The truth? Boring, in the best way: people are moving for family, for career advancement, for fresh starts.
If management drama was lurking, you’d expect local media blogs or trades to poke at it by now. But a spin through coverage on ConnectiveMag and other media-job sites? Nada. No exposé. No whistleblowers. Not even a mysterious “source familiar with the matter.”
Meanwhile, What Happens Next at Fox 17?
It’s worth noting — the station itself isn’t just limping along. Fox 17 has actively recruited new anchors and faces, as the news cycle demands. This isn’t a ghost town; it’s a newsroom in motion.
What’s more, stations usually plan for this. They stack up résumés, cross-train multi-hyphenate staff, and rotate in hungry new recruits. Sure, there might be a little more green on the set, but that’s broadcast life.
Media companies are used to “The Talent Shuffle.” The show — and the 5 a.m. wake-up calls — always go on.
The Bottom Line? No Crisis, Just Career Moves
If you’re a Fox 17 viewer wondering where your favorite anchor went, the answer is more ordinary than the rumor mill says.
Yes, it’s a wave of departures. No, it’s not a mass exodus or a “fallen empire.” The root causes — per the people themselves — are family, change of scenery, and new jobs. It happens, it’s public, and for the station, it’s business as usual.
Would it be juicier if there was an airtight exposé or corporate intrigue? Sure. But that’s not what’s showing up in any actual statement or credible coverage.
If you’re a manager, you know the drill: talented people leave for all kinds of reasons, and rarely at a convenient time. Your job is to make sure the work — or, in Fox 17’s case, the news — keeps coming in loud, clear, and on time.
So, while viewers miss their favorites, the business of TV news rolls forward — one anchor, one meteorologist, and one new farewell cake at a time.
Crisis? Not quite. Just another round in the media echo chamber — and tomorrow morning, the show airs right on schedule.
Also Read: